Who is West Ham’s best ever penalty taker?

West Ham United's Mark Noble (left) is congratulated by First team coach Julian Dicks at the final w

West Ham United's Mark Noble (left) is congratulated by First team coach Julian Dicks at the final whistle - Credit: PA Archive/PA Images

The Hammers have had three stand-out stars from the spot, but who is the best?

West Ham United's Ray Stewart celebrates scoring a penalty past Notts County goalkeeper Raddy Avramo

West Ham United's Ray Stewart celebrates scoring a penalty past Notts County goalkeeper Raddy Avramovich (l) - Credit: PA Archive/PA Images

When you look at the history of West Ham penalties, three men stand head and shoulders above the rest.

Sir Geoff Hurst used to take them, but his miss in the League Cup semi-final against Stoke City in 1972 stands out.

Billy Bonds had a go for a while, of course he did, while Geoff Pike missed one in a relegation battle against Manchester United, only to make up for it by scoring from open play.

Paolo Di Canio managed a few in his time, while Johnny Byrne and John Bond also had their moments.

West Ham United's Mark Noble scores his side's first goal of the game from a penalty during the Prem

West Ham United's Mark Noble scores his side's first goal of the game from a penalty during the Premier League match at London Stadium. - Credit: PA Archive/PA Images


You may also want to watch:


But no-one comes close to our top three of Scotland international Ray Stewart, current skipper Mark Noble and the 'Terminator' Julian Dicks.

None of them attackers, but all three with nerves of steel and in the case of Stewart and Dicks, a no-nonsense ability to absolutely thump it.

Most Read

In third place for us is Dicks, who scored 36 times from 12 yards, missing just seven.

His most memorable came in December 1996 against champions Manchester United at Upton Park.

West Ham United's captain Julian Dicks shoots at goal during their London FA Carling Premiership der

West Ham United's captain Julian Dicks shoots at goal during their London FA Carling Premiership derby against Wimbledon at Selhurst Park tonight (Tuesday). Photo By Rebecca Naden/PA - Credit: PA Archive/PA Images

United had led 2-0, but back came the Hammers to pull one back, before Michael Hughes won a spot-kick with 12 minutes left.

Up stepped Dicks to hammer the ball past Peter Schmeichel and earn a stunning 2-2 draw.

Noble is a very different sort of penalty-taker, but percentage wise the most effective.

He likes to send the keeper the wrong way and his record of 36 goals and four misses is second to none for the Hammers.

Ray Stewart scores from the spot

Ray Stewart scores from the spot - Credit: Archant

He likens his penalties to the ones he used to take down the park as a kid and it seems to do the trick.

Despite that, he has lost the spot-kick duties on two occasions.

First to Italian Alessandro Diamanti, who scored four of his eight goals in claret and blue from the spot in the 2009-10 season under Gianfranco Zola.

Then at the beginning of last season, Noble handed the reins over to Marco Arnautovic as the club tried to persuade him to stay.

West Ham United's Mark Noble scores his side's first goal of the game from the penalty spot during t

West Ham United's Mark Noble scores his side's first goal of the game from the penalty spot during the Premier League match at London Stadium. - Credit: PA Wire/PA Images

They didn't manage it and the Austrian only scored one.

But the champion penalty-taker for the Hammers has to be Stewart.

He took over from Bonds after arriving in 1979 and during his 11 seasons at the club, he was renowned for his thumping strikes which earned him the nickname of 'Tonka'.

Often he hit the ball so hard that he would have two feet off the ground as he hit it.

File photo dated 30-01-1999 of West Ham captain Julian Dicks.

File photo dated 30-01-1999 of West Ham captain Julian Dicks. - Credit: PA Archive/PA Images

He scored 76 penalties and missed 10, with three being put in on the rebound, two by himself and one by Paul Goddard.

Five of his misses were saved and two went wide.

Stewart scored some vital goals as well.

In the FA Cup quarter-final against Aston Villa at Upton Park, he scored the last-minute winner for the second division side with a nerveless finish.

West Ham United's Paul Allen and Geoff Pike celebrate with the FA Cup as teammate Ray Stewart makes

West Ham United's Paul Allen and Geoff Pike celebrate with the FA Cup as teammate Ray Stewart makes do with the trophy lid. - Credit: PA Archive/PA Images

A year later, he was at it again in the League Cup final at Wembley against mighty Liverpool.

After Alan Kennedy's controversdial goal seemed to have gifted the cup to the Reds, Liverpool handballed in the 120th minute and Stewart struck again.

Noble has a long way to go if he wants to catch Stewart, but these are stunning statistics and to have three players with such great records is a remarkable achievement.

But Stewart is King!

1st: ray stewart 88.37%

'Tonka' as he was known, was a prolific thumper of the ball from the penalty spot at West Ham.

In his 11 seasons at the club, the Scotland international scored 76 penalties, missing 10, of which three were scored from the rebound.

Two of them were his own rebounds, while the other fell for Paul Goddard.

2nd: MARK NOBLE 90%

'With 36 successful penalties and only four misses, 'Nobes' has the best percentage record of our top spot-kick men.

It is only the fact that Stewart has many more kicks to his name that he is not number one.

3rd: julian dicks 84%

'Dicksie' used brute force for his penalties thumping them past the keeper.

Become a Supporter

This newspaper has been a central part of community life for many years. Our industry faces testing times, which is why we're asking for your support. Every contribution will help us continue to produce local journalism that makes a measurable difference to our community.

Become a Supporter
Comments powered by Disqus