Comment: Football reels after latest racism shame but fanzine writer insists sick chants are rare

08:15 30 November 2012

Copies of West Ham United fanzine Over Land And Sea on sale outside Upton Park. Photo credit: Nick Potts/PA wire

Copies of West Ham United fanzine Over Land And Sea on sale outside Upton Park. Photo credit: Nick Potts/PA wire

PA Archive/Press Association Images

If last year’s Premier League campaign will be remembered for its thrilling finale, the current season is in danger of being overshadowed by a series of scandals that are threatening the reputation of the English game.

"I couldn’t believe it at first. I’m not easily shocked by what I’ve heard at Upton Park over the years, which is far milder than it used to be, but that really did stop me in my tracks"

Antony Randle on the only other time he heard anti-Semitic chanting at a football match

Whether the offenders be players or the fans who sing their names, the seriousness of the situation is becoming abundantly clear.

The anti-Semitic chanting by a section of West Ham supporters in Sunday’s clash with Spurs at White Hart Lane was the latest unsavoury incident, quickly following others involving Chelsea and Millwall earlier in the season. While the police have moved to investigate some of those involved, are we any closer to finding a solution to the issue of racism in the Premier League?

Antony Randle, who is a regular contributor to the West Ham fanzine ‘Over Land and Sea’ (OLAS) and attended his first match at Upton Park in 1975, says such occurrences are few and far between.

“I can vividly recall the first, and to date, only time I heard the sort of chanting which apparently took place on Sunday. It was a game against Spurs in the early 80s at Upton Park when I used to stand on the North Bank.

West Ham United flag. Photo credit: Jon Buckle/EMPICSWest Ham United flag. Photo credit: Jon Buckle/EMPICS

“I suddenly became aware of this ‘ssssss’ hissing noise followed by a chant of ‘Gas the Jews.’

“I couldn’t believe it at first. I’m not easily shocked by what I’ve heard at Upton Park over the years, which is far milder than it used to be, but that really did stop me in my tracks. More so than the occasional monkey noises which used to be aired occasionally in those days, though even then they were pretty rare and confined to individuals rather than groups.”

Despite the similar chants at White Hart Lane on Sunday, Randle is adamant that even in games against Spurs, racially abusive chanting is still uncommon.

“Upton Park isn’t the bear-pit it used to be,” he said. “It was a much more hostile place in the 70s and 80s where you would see occasional confrontations on the South Bank between home fans and the opposition, but even those were relatively rare.

“It’s a much less febrile atmosphere today where apart from the Millwall incident two or three years ago [a riot at a Carling Cup match] I haven’t seen or been around any crowd trouble for a couple of decades at least.”

But the anti-Semitic chanting at the weekend exemplifies the problems the authorities have in stamping it out. Clearly those who would sing about the Holocaust are beyond education.

Despite their team being part-owned by David Gold, represented by Yossi Benayoun, and managed previously by Avram Grant, all of whom are Jewish, some people cannot be taught tolerance.

But they can be reprimanded, and in the wake of recent events, fines and lifetime bans seem to fall short of the mark if we are to rid English football from this stain on its character.

Fans who will indulge in the sick practice of exploiting the systematic extermination of six million Jews to ridicule a rival football team will thankfully always be the minority. The problem is that these pockets of fans will always have the capacity to make themselves heard, as we saw with the banners raised by Millwall fans abusing Bolton striker Marvin Sordell, though the Lions acted commendably in speedily dishing out punishments.

The FA has to come to terms with the fact that racism and anti-Semitism have not been altogether eradicated from the game in this country. To respond they must explore the possibilities of harsher punishments such as awarding the other team victory, or docking them points. The Professional Footballers’ Association and the Football Association must set about devising new ways to combat this behaviour, both to banish it from our leagues, and to set an example to other countries, many of whom are more profoundly affected by racism than we are.

Related articles


Latest Sport Stories

Ravi Bopara with his old team and action from the Oakfield Parkonians Cricket Club

England all-rounder agrees new two-year deal with the Eagles

Ravi Bopara
Leyton Orient goalkeeper Alex Cisak has his goal put under pressure at Crawley (pic: Simon O'Connor).

Brisbane Road boss confirms club won’t appeal Alan Dunne’s dismissal during 3-2 loss at Crawley Town

Alex Cisak
The Essex Senior League season is well underway

Chadfields outfit have lost last eight matches in all competitions

Essex Senior League
Great Britain beat France in their first match at the BT Wheelchair Rugby World Challenge at the Copper Box

A round-up of the action on day one at the Copper Box

United Kingdom

Most read sport


Angharad Baa Stool in Rare Breed.

Great British Life is offering a sheepskin footstool worth £199 to a lucky reader

Read more
Amazon: Everything you want to buy all in one place!

With £1,500 to spend online at Amazon, there’s really nothing you can’t buy.

Read more
You'll be stocked up on toiletries  for a while!

Cosmetics, toiletries, vitamins and more.

Read more

Digital Edition

Read the Newham Recorder e-edition today E-edition
Family Notices 24

Local business directory

Our trusted business finder