Search

Claret & Hugh: Allardyce must embrace the West Ham way... or he’ll never win us over

07:00 23 April 2014

West Ham manager Sam Allardyce. (Photo by Christopher Lee/Getty Images)

West Ham manager Sam Allardyce. (Photo by Christopher Lee/Getty Images)

2014 Getty Images

Our scribe from the wonderful West Ham blog, Claret & Hugh, believes manager Sam Allardyce needs to make some drastic changes to the Hammers’ playing style...

About our blogger

Name: Hugh Southon

Twitter: @hughsouthon

Website: www.claretandhugh.info

Favourite player: Winston Reid

Most memorable game: 1964 FA Cup semi-final v Manchester United

Predicted finish: 11th

As the Hammers limp towards the end of a truly depressing season, talk of the ‘West Ham way’ emerges more and more on numerous club websites.

The phrase was dismissed pretty brutally by Sam Allardyce when it was raised back in 2012 and Alan Shearer won no friends among us when he rubbished the expression on Match of the Day at the weekend.

Both men should know better given the template was put in place by legendary manager Ron Greenwood (who could even lay claim to winning England our one and only World Cup!), continued by his disciple John Lyall and followed faithfully by Harry Redknapp.

Okay, it started to get lost after that but whether Sam or Shearer like it or not, most of us who have followed the team for more years than we might like to remember, continue to see it as part of our Boleyn DNA.

It was never better expressed than in the words of Greenwood himself who said this: “The crowds at West Ham have never been rewarded by results but they keep turning up because of the good football they see. Other clubs will suffer from the old bugbear that results count more than anything. This has been the ruination of English soccer.”

Mr Allardyce – in that infamous interview on Sky Sports - claimed that such a way was a delusion. Responding to the question from Gary Cotterill, he responded: “It sounds like not winning.”

He continued: “There has never been a ‘West Ham way’ shown to me, not by anyone who has worked at the club. I’ve spoken to a lot of people at the club and no one can tell me what it is, so it is a bit of a delusion.”

Well, hopefully I’ve managed to help him understand, via the lips of the legendary Mr Greenwood, what it is and as a result help him in his quest to perhaps gain a little more popularity among the fans who appear to be rising up against the ‘Sam way’.

On the Claret & Hugh website a few weeks ago, we ran a poll asking whether Sam should stay or go. Result: Opinion was divided right down the middle.

As I write we have another poll running which asks: “Should West Ham achieve results by any means or should the first priority be to entertain?”

The current state of the poll shows nearly two to one in favour of an entertaining with many voicing a sad critique of what they have been seeing this season.

The words hoofball, route one, direct, predictable and one dimensional are now such common currency when discussing the Irons style that it’s hard to deny their credibility.

Three defeats at home, the Hull City match where the booing became the major topic and the weekend Palace shambles are reminders of what is sticking in the fans gullets.

Whether the manager accepts there has ever been a ‘West Ham way’ or not (and of course there has) he seems oblivious to the fact that his own way is not acceptable to a large number.

His way has of course been built around Andy Carroll’s head and as recent results are showing, that ain’t working. His way appears to always involve playing a big man up front without a natural partner!

Also it has to be said that ‘Sam’s way’ – like the perception he has of the ‘West Ham way’ – is also a losing way right now.

However, he did his best at the weekend to get onside with the fans by saying he’s as “frustrated” as them. But he’s got it wrong. It’s not frustration we are feeling but FEAR.

A fear we may still go down, fear that it will be more of the same next year and fear that we have deserted the West Ham Way for ever if he doesn’t actually know what it is.

All the arguments are out there for sticking with this way, chiefly that Allardyce is a bomb-proof punt against relegation.

Thus far that’s proved to be the case, but at what cost in terms of watchability? And surely it’s reasonable to expect a degree of flexibility within a system which appears to be becoming increasingly straightforward for teams to read?

Change surely has to be on the Hammers agenda for next season both in terms of personnel and tactics.

Related articles

Latest Newham Sports News

Yesterday, 16:00
Leyton Orient's badge outside Brisbane Road (pic: Play With A Legend).

Ex-Oldham Athletic ace will play his first home match at E10 and has discussed his role in helping improve the youngsters in the squad

Russell Slade
Yesterday, 13:02
New Leyton Orient midfielder Robbie Weir shows his delight after signing for the club (pic: Leyton Orient FC).

Experienced midfielder has demonstrated his leadership qualities throughout the summer

Nicky Hunt
Yesterday, 12:00
Russell Slade (left) and Kevin Nugent will return to Brisbane Road this weekend with Charlton Athletic (pic: Simon O'Connor).

Pair who worked together for a lengthy amount of time at Brisbane Road will return on Saturday with League One side Charlton

Nicky Hunt
Thu, 16:00
Liam Kelly in action for Oldham against Blackpool last season (pic: Empics)

One time Scotland internationals reflects on his transfer and the possibility of earning promotion from League Two

National League

Newsletter Sign Up

Most read sport

HOT JOBS

Show Job Lists

Competitions

Which book character do you share cleaning habits with?

Whether you have more in common with put-upon Cinderella, emotionally turbulent Jane Eyre, or easily distracted Mole, you’re sure to appreciate four sessions of free cleaning. Enter our quiz for your chance to win. All entrants can get £10 off their first clean when making a repeat booking.

Read more
£15k prize bundle

Imagine having the opportunity to win an incredible £15,000 bundle of some of the most amazing prizes available. Well, for one lucky contest entrant that dream could soon become a reality because we at MyOffers are offering an incredible free prize bundle that will make even the most hardened person wild with excitement.

Read more

Digital Edition

cover

Enjoy the
Newham Recorder
e-edition today

Subscribe

Education and Training

cover

Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now