Search

Hammer-attack man from Manor Park loses appeal

17:00 05 November 2012

A drug-addled thug who battered a passer-by with a claw hammer after vowing to attack “the first person he saw” has failed to convince top judges he was too harshly punished.

Minesh Patel, of First Avenue, Manor Park, was caged indefinitely for public protection - which is almost identical to a life term - at Inner London Crown Court in May this year after he was convicted of wounding with intent.

Patel, 30, suffers from paranoid schizophrenia, London’s Appeal Court heard, which he is able to control through medication, except when using cannabis.

At the time of the hammer attack in October last year Patel had been smoking cannabis throughout the night, and woke up in an agitated state.

“When he came to in the early morning he picked up a claw hammer and went out with the intention of hitting someone with it,” said Mr Justice Hickinbottom.

“He intended to hit the first person he saw, and said he had bursts of violence in his subconscious”.

Patel’s hapless victim was ambushed as she walked to work, the court heard, suffering serious injuries when he struck her from behind before fleeing down the street.

Mr Justice Hickinbottom, sitting with Lord Justice Pitchford and Judge Guy Boney QC, said Patel knew that violent outbursts could be triggered by taking cannabis and should have known better than to dabble in drugs.

Fortunately his victim escaped really major injuries, said the judge, but that was “only by providence”. Patel’s “culpability” was very high, he added, and the sentencing judge was entitled to find him dangerous.

“He took a claw hammer onto the streets, and intended doing the first stranger he met some really serious harm. It’s only by providence that severe harm was not done,” said the judge.

Patel’s open-ended sentence means he will only be freed when, and if, the Parole Board is convinced that the danger he poses to society has passed.

Latest News Stories

49 minutes ago
Visually-impaired Imtiaz Patel says he has enough problems at East Ham station as it is

A major transport charity claims London Mayor Boris Johnson risks undermining the freedom of disabled commuters by removing Tube ticket offices.

Boris Johnson
Stephen Timms tells reporter Sebastian Murphy-Bates why East Ham should vote Labour on May 7

Stephen Timms tells Manor Park event Labour is the right choice for East Ham

Stephen Timms
15:01
Emmanuel Nwamadi

A talented singer from Forest Gate will perform for the nation this weekend in the live final of BBC’s The Voice.

BBC
London City Airport has been denied expansion by Boris Johnson

This week our Big Debate asks if Boris Johnson was right to halt London City Airport’s expansion

Boris Johnson

Most read news

Competitions

Munch on a tasy three course dinner at The Refinery!

“Where to go for a drink near Great Portland Street?” was previously met with blank expressions and shrugs for those local to the area, not anymore, thanks to the opening of The Refinery at Regent’s Place, the eighth bar and restaurant from hugely-successful group Drake & Morgan.

Read more
Funky adidias iPhone cases up for grabs!

We’ve teamed up with adidas Originals to give away four iPhone 5/5s cases.

Read more

Digital Edition

Image
Read the Newham Recorder e-edition today E-edition
Family Notices 24


Our trusted business finder