ExCeL arms fair protesters should not have been acquitted, High Court rules

PUBLISHED: 14:06 14 July 2017

The DSEI arms fair at the ExCeL in 2015

The DSEI arms fair at the ExCeL in 2015


Eight anti-arms trade protesters accused of unlawfully disrupting an arms fair at the ExCeL should not have been acquitted, the High Court has ruled.

A judge at Stratford Magistrates’ Court cleared them in April 2016 after accepting their argument they had tried to prevent greater crimes, such as genocide and torture, by blocking a road to stop tanks and other armoured vehicles from arriving at the Defence & Security Equipment International (DSEI) exhibition in 2015 where they claimed illegal arms trading was taking place.

But now two High Court judges have ruled District Judge Angus Hamilton “misdirected himself in law” when he permitted the protesters to use the crime prevention defence under section 3 of the Criminal Law Act 1967.

Expert witness had told the judge there were historic breaches of UK arms exports controls at previous DSEI exhibitions.

Quashing the acquittals following an application by the Director of Public Prosecutions, Lord Justice Simon and Sir Kenneth Parker said the preventing crime defence was not relevant because there was no evidence that the commission of a crime was “imminent and immediate” at the time the eight chained themselves up outside the centre.

There was no evidence of any illegal arms trading at the 2015 exhibition but the protesters regarded it as reasonable to assume the level of illegal activity was similar to what had allegedly occurred at earlier events, said Lord Justice Simon.

The court decided not to order a retrial, saying it was not necessary in the “overall interests of justice” for several reasons, including the eight were of previous good character.

Isa Al-Aali, from Bahrain; Lisa Butler, Angela Ditchfield, Thomas Franklin and Susannah Mengesha, all from the UK; Javier Garate Neidhart, from Chile; Luis Tinoco Torrejon, from Peru, and Bram Vranken, from Belgium, had all denied wilful obstruction of the highway.

After the High Court ruling in London, they said they remained “wholeheartedly unrepentant” for their actions.

A group statement said: “We cannot rely on the Theresa Mays and Donald Trumps of this world, whose idea of keeping us safe and promoting human rights abroad is to arm despotic terroristic head-chopping regimes such as Saudi to the teeth.”

Latest Newham Stories

National League: Braintree Town 1 Leyton Orient 5

Yesterday, 19:28

Centuries from Simon Harmer and Tom Westley put Essex in complete command against Surrey at the Kia Oval, where the champions ended day two facing their first defeat of a triumphant season.

Jamie Porter
Yesterday, 17:00

Justin Edinburgh’s team could break a club record this evening

Justin Edinburgh
Yesterday, 19:00

The Financial Conduct Authority has opened its new headquarters in Stratford.

Canning Town

Hammers’ Lukasz Fabianski is imporoving with every game

Yesterday, 13:00

Clapton boss Jonny Fowell had plenty of praise for Barkingside manager Michael Walther despite sealing a 3-0 victory against his side on Friday evening.

Michael Walther
Yesterday, 16:31

A St John Ambulance volunteer from Canary Wharf has received an award for his first aid work around Newham.

Yesterday, 15:57

Newham’s best and brightest were recognised at the annual Jack Petchey Awards.

Newham Council


Hanson Fernandes’ journey began in 2015 when he arrived in London from Goa, India.

Newsletter Sign Up

Newham Recorder twice-weekly newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy

Most read news

Show Job Lists

Education Promo

Digital Edition


Enjoy the
Newham Recorder
e-edition today


Education and Training


Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now